You Lost Credibility the Day the Pushback Stopped

I was talking to an engineering leader recently who'd built a mandatory architecture review into their process. It was not popular. Engineers would show up, push back, argue the decisions getting made… annoying in the moment, but it worked. There was a healthy friction to it.

A year later the friction was gone. Which sounds like progress… except the reviews hadn't gotten better. People had just found ways around them. The reviewer got pulled in after things were already built, if at all, and nobody said anything until something shipped with consequences the review would have caught. The process wasn't the problem. Credibility was, and it had been eroding the whole time without anyone noticing.

That's the part that stuck with me: you don't lose credibility on the day people push back on you. You already lost it on the day they stopped bothering.

The instinct from there is to hold the process tighter… make it more mandatory, escalate it up the chain. But that's backwards. Tightening doesn't win trust back, it just confirms whatever made people start routing around you in the first place. What actually worked was raising the value where the review could move faster, and raising the visibility of everything that couldn't… showing people what the review was catching before they'd already decided working around it was worth it. Engineers came back, not because they were told to, but because showing up was worth it.

You don't get credibility back by holding people to a process. You get it back by building one they want to be part of.

0:00 The architecture review that worked… until the pushback stopped

0:41 It wasn't the process eroding, it was credibility

1:00 Why tightening the process is exactly backwards

1:15 The two things that won it back

1:47 What happened when the review earned its place

SUBSCRIBE for more insights on leadership, product, and technology

Newsletter: https://www.nathanbroslawsky.com

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/broslawsky

#leadership #engineering #management #technology #collaboration #cto